Skip to main content

33.5 Cloud vs. On-Premise Considerations

Overview​

Cloud vs. on-premise is an important decision when choosing accounting software. Cloud software is hosted online and accessed via internet, while on-premise software is installed on your own computers. Each has advantages and disadvantages that must be considered.

Cloud Software​

What is Cloud Software?​

Cloud Software:

  • Hosted on vendor's servers
  • Accessed via internet browser
  • Data stored in cloud
  • Automatic updates
  • Subscription-based pricing

Advantages​

Cloud Advantages:

  • Accessibility: Access from anywhere
  • No installation: No software installation needed
  • Automatic updates: Updates handled by vendor
  • Backup: Automatic backups
  • Scalability: Easy to scale
  • Lower upfront cost: Subscription vs. license

Disadvantages​

Cloud Disadvantages:

  • Internet dependency: Requires internet connection
  • Data security concerns: Data stored externally
  • Ongoing costs: Subscription fees
  • Less control: Less control over system
  • Vendor dependency: Dependent on vendor

On-Premise Software​

What is On-Premise Software?​

On-Premise Software:

  • Installed on your computers
  • Data stored locally
  • Managed by you
  • One-time license purchase
  • Manual updates

Advantages​

On-Premise Advantages:

  • Control: Full control over system
  • Data security: Data stored locally
  • No internet required: Works offline
  • One-time cost: License purchase
  • Customization: More customization options

Disadvantages​

On-Premise Disadvantages:

  • Installation: Requires installation
  • Maintenance: You manage maintenance
  • Backup: You manage backups
  • Updates: Manual updates
  • Higher upfront cost: License purchase
  • IT resources: May need IT support

Comparison​

Cost Comparison​

AspectCloudOn-Premise
Upfront CostLow (subscription)High (license)
Ongoing CostMonthly/annual subscriptionMaintenance fees
Total CostPredictable monthlyVaries
Long-termOngoing paymentsOne-time + maintenance

Security Comparison​

AspectCloudOn-Premise
Data LocationVendor serversYour servers
SecurityVendor responsibilityYour responsibility
BackupAutomaticYour responsibility
ComplianceVendor complianceYour compliance

Choosing Between Cloud and On-Premise​

Factors to Consider​

Consider:

  • Business size: Small businesses may prefer cloud
  • IT resources: Limited IT favors cloud
  • Security requirements: High security may favor on-premise
  • Budget: Upfront vs. ongoing costs
  • Access needs: Remote access favors cloud
  • Control needs: High control needs favor on-premise

Hybrid Solutions​

Hybrid Approach​

Hybrid Options:

  • Cloud for some functions, on-premise for others
  • Cloud backup of on-premise data
  • Cloud access to on-premise system
  • Best of both worlds

Luxembourg Compliance Note​

Compliance Considerations:

  • Data location: Cloud data may be stored outside Luxembourg
  • Data protection: GDPR compliance required
  • Backup requirements: 10-year retention applies to both
  • Access requirements: Must be able to access data
  • Security: Both must meet security requirements

Recommendations:

  • Cloud: Good for small businesses, remote access needs
  • On-premise: Good for large businesses, high security needs
  • Consider: Data location, security, compliance requirements
  • Evaluate: Cost, features, support for each option

Think It Through​

TechLux Solutions needs to choose between cloud and on-premise accounting software. They have 10 employees, need remote access, and have limited IT resources. Which option is better?

Concepts in Practice​

Cloud vs. On-Premise Decision

TechLux Solutions evaluation:

Requirements:

  • Remote access needed
  • Limited IT resources
  • Budget-conscious
  • Need automatic backups
  • PCN compliance required

Cloud Option:

  • ✅ Remote access
  • ✅ No IT resources needed
  • ✅ Lower upfront cost
  • ✅ Automatic backups
  • ✅ PCN compliance
  • ⚠️ Ongoing subscription cost
  • ⚠️ Internet dependency

On-Premise Option:

  • ❌ Limited remote access
  • ❌ IT resources needed
  • ❌ Higher upfront cost
  • ❌ Manual backups
  • ✅ PCN compliance
  • ✅ One-time cost
  • ✅ No internet dependency

Decision: Cloud chosen for remote access, lower upfront cost, automatic backups.

Result: Cloud solution implemented, meets requirements, efficient operations.